|
Aaron
S. Geller, M.D.
|
PAIN
|
Before
Treatment
|
After
Treatment
|
|
|
Directions to Dr. Geller's offices
To get to Dr. Geller’s
NASHUA office
near the Nashua Mall, one block off the Everett Turnpike, 30 minutes
south
of Concord, take 93 South to 293 South, then veer left to the Everett
Turnpike
and take exit #6 to 130-West. At the first set of lights, make a U-turn
back to the highway. After you pass the Shell gas station, take an
immediate
right at 150 Broad Street at the Carlson Real Estate Building. Continue
through the parking lot past the Japanese Bistro to the adjacent
building
at 154 Broad Street, Nashua, NH 03063.
This web site is constantly being
updated and
evolving as new pain related research is reviewed. To avoid
constantly
re-reading the same material, the visitor is encouraged to make a note
of the number of references cited at the end of the article. New
versions will have more references.
As this site was hastened to be posted
in August
2003 at the request of numerous patients, the visitor is requested to
appreciate
that grammatical corrections and redundancy will be corrected, and
addition
of pending references will be forthcoming. The authors apologize
and anticipate prompt refinement to this site.
The material herein is notarized,
copyright Aaron
S. Geller, M.D. DBA Nashua Pain Management. All rights
reserved.
The material herein reflects the
extensive research
and experience of the author. Any medication discussed herein
must
be prescribed and consumed in accord with the prescribing information
released
from the manufacturer.
Clinical Pearls in Pain
Management 4/18/04
by
Aaron S. Geller, M.D. and
Sharon
M. Geller, MS, PT
OBJECTIVES:
The clinician will appreciate;
Different mechanisms of action of
different analgesic
classes act via excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmitters, distinct
sites
and circuits in the peripheral and central nervous system, and
different
combinations of sodium, calcium, and potassium ion effects to achieve
pain
relief. This is reflected in pain management by embracement of a
polymodal treatment strategy utilizing agents of several classes to
maximize
analgesia and limit side effects.
Individual medications of analgesic
classes of
antidepressants, NSAID’s, opioids, anticonvulsants, anti-arrhythmics,
and
spasmolytics have structural distinctiveness such that different trials
within each class can be pursued to effect antinociception in accord
with
each patient’s unique biophysiology.
The efficacy of the spectrum of topical
medications,
a limited number of systemic agents, and injections are often employed
to limit cognitive and other side effects in the management of
pain.
Topical medications may include sodium or calcium antagonists, NMDA
blockers,
opioids, and anticonvulsants.
Novel analgesics may be employed to
attenuate
pain, including T/N calcium channel blockers, substance P inhibitors,
oral
cannaboid receptor agonists, and NMDA antagonists.
Co-prescription of combinations of
analgesics
may potentiate pain relief in a supra-additive manner with limitation
of
side effects limited to simple additivity.
Treatment of mood depression, anxiety,
obesity,
fatigue, insomnia, and other comorbid conditions must be integral to
comprehensive
pain management to maximally reduce pain and enhance function.
Opioids are narcotic analgesics written
by clinicians,
not DEA, state police, FBI, Board of Medicine, or Board of
Pharmacy.
Clinicians who elect to prescribe such medications must embrace the
responsibility
of screening for addiction and diversion. Strategies will be
presented.
Opioids are safe and effective for
chronic use
for the patient truly suffering in pain. Tolerance is a rare
event,
but addiction and criminal diversion are not rare nor are they
victimless
crimes.
OUTLINE OF CHAPTERS
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF PAIN – SCOPE OF THE
CONDITION
CLASSIFICATION OF PAIN
PAIN MANAGEMENT TREATMENT GOALS
MECHANISMS OF PAIN – PHYSIOLOGY
PATHOPHYSIOLOGIC MECHANISMS OF ACUTE AND
CHRONIC
PAIN
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – CALCIUM CHANNELS
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – CALCIUM CHANNEL
BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – SODIUM CHANNELS
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – SODIUM CHANNEL
BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – POTASSIUM CHANNELS
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – POTASSIUM CHANNEL
BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
MEASUREMENT OF PAIN
DIAGNOSIS
EMERGENCIES
TREATMENT OF PAIN
COMORBID CONDITIONS
COMORBID CONDITIONS – MOOD DEPRESSION
COMORBID CONDITIONS – ANXIETY
COMORBID CONDITIONS – OBESITY
COMORBID OBESITY – TREATMENT – IMPAIRING
FAT
ABSORPTION
COMORBID OBESITY – TREATMENT – SUPPRESSING
APPETITE
COMORBID CONDITIONS – MYOFASCIAL PAIN /
FIBROMYALGIA
COMORBID CONDITIONS – SMOKING TOBACCO
COMORBID CONDITIONS – INSOMNIA
COMORBID CONDITIONS – RESTLESS LEGS SYNDROME
COMORBID CONDITIONS – ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION
COMORBID CONDITIONS – CHRONIC FATIGUE
COMORBID CHRONIC FATIGUE – TREATMENT–
MODAFINIL
COMORBID CHRONIC FATIGUE – TREATMENT–
ADDITIONAL
OPTIONS
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS –
ORTHOSTATIC
HYPOTENSION
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – XEROSTOMIA
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS –
CONSTIPATION
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – URINARY
RETENTION
NON-ANALGESIC MEDICATIONS
ANALGESIC MEDICATIONS
MEDICATIONS – SYNERGISM OF COMBINATIONS OF
ANALGESICS
MEDICATIONS – ANTAGONISM OF COMBINATIONS OF
ANALGESICS
MEDICATIONS – GLUCOSAMINE AND CHONDROITIN
MEDICATIONS – ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES –
STEROIDS
MEDICATIONS – ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES – ORAL
STEROIDS
MEDICATIONS – ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES –
INTRA-ARTICULAR
STEROIDS
MEDICATIONS – INTRA-ARTICULAR STEROIDS –
SACRO-ILIAC
JOINTS
MEDICATIONS – INTRA-ARTICULAR STEROIDS –
EPIDURAL
STEROIDS
MEDICATIONS - ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES –
LIPOXYGENASE
ANTAGONISTS
MEDICATIONS - ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES –
CYCLOOXYGENASE
(COX) ANTAGONISTS
MEDICATIONS – NSAID’S – STRUCTURAL CLASSES
MEDICATIONS – NSAID’S – ASPIRIN
MEDICATIONS –NSAID’S – NEGATIVE GI
CONSIDERATIONS
MEDICATIONS – COX-2 SELECTIVE NSAID’S
MEDICATIONS – NONSELECTIVE NSAID BLEEDING
CONSIDERATIONS
OTHER
THAN COX-2 RELATED ISSUES
MEDICATIONS – NSAID’S – PRESCRIBING
RECOMMENDATIONS
MEDICATIONS – NSAID’S –GI CONSIDERATIONS –
PPI’s
MEDICATIONS – COX BLOCKING NSAID’s –
NEGATIVE
RENAL CONSIDERATIONS
MEDICATIONS – COX INHIBITING NSAID’s –
CHRONIC
PAIN
MEDICATIONS – ACETAMINOPHEN
MEDICATIONS – TOPICAL MEDICATIONS
MEDICATIONS – MUSCLE RELAXANTS
MEDICATIONS – MUSCLE RELAXANTS – SPECIFIC
AGENTS
MEDICATIONS – ANTIDEPRESSANTS
MEDICATIONS – TRICYCLIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
MEDICATIONS – DOPAMINERGIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
MEDICATIONS – SEROTONERGIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
MEDICATIONS – ANTIHISTAMINES
MEDICATIONS – ANTICONVULSANTS
MEDICATIONS – ANTI-ARRHYTHMICS
MEDICATIONS – PERIPHERAL ALPHA BLOCKING
ANTIHYPERTENSIVES
MEDICATIONS – SUBSTANCE P INHIBITORS
MEDICATIONS – BISPHOSPHONATES
MEDICATIONS – CALCITONIN
MEDICATIONS – DOPAMINE RECEPTOR BLOCKING
MOOD
STABILIZERS
MEDICATIONS – NARCOTICS
MEDICATIONS – NMDA BLOCKERS
MEDICATIONS – CANNABINOID RECEPTOR AGONISTS
MARIJUANA
MEDICATIONS – PSYCHOSTIMULANTS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – CURING PAIN
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – SUPRA-ADDITIVITY
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – OPIOID RECEPTOR
SUBTYPES
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – OPIOID TYPES
REALITY, OPIOID RECEPTORS, AND OPIOID TYPE
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS - PSEUDOADDICTION
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – DEPENDENCE –
PATIENT
CONCERNS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS - ADDICTION
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – ADDICTION – PATIENT
CONCERNS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – ADDICTION –
PHYSICIAN
CONCERNS
OPIOID DIVERSION - CRIMINALS
OPIOIDS – INSIGHTS INTO WORKER’S
COMPENSATION
OPIOIDS – PRACTICE POLICIES TO LIMIT
DIVERSION
OPIOID – PRACTICE POLICIES TO LIMIT
DIVERSION
– OPIOID CONTRACT
MEDICATIONS – SHORT LASTING OPIOIDS –
BENEFICIAL
USES
MEDICATIONS – SHORT LASTING OPIOIDS –
DETRIMENTAL
CONSIDERATIONS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – SPECIFIC SHORT
LASTING
PURE AGONISTS
MEDICATIONS – SHORT LASTING OPIOIDS –
TRAMODOL
MEDICATIONS – SHORT LASTING OPIOIDS –
MEPERIDINE
MEDICATIONS – SHORT LASTING OPIOIDS –
PROPOXYPHENE
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – SPECIFIC
AGONISTS/ANTAGONISTS
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS –AGONIST/ANTAGONIST
COMBINED
WITH PURE ANTAGONISTS
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS – WHEN
TO
USE TWO AGENTS
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
OXYCONTIN
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
OXYMORPHONE
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS -
MORPHINE
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
METHADONE
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
METHADONE
– NEGATIVE ASPECTS
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
LEVORPHANOL
MEDICATIONS – LONG LASTING OPIOIDS –
FENTANYL
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS –TOLERANCE, A RARE
HUMAN
PHENOMENON
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – PSEUDOTOLERANCE
MEDICATIONS – OPIOIDS – MANAGEMENT OF TRUE
TOLERANCE
OPIOID INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS
OPIOID INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – NAUSEA
OPIOID INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – PRURITUS
OPIOID INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – HYPERALGESIA
OPIOID INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS – DYSPHORIA
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – TRIGGER POINT
INJECTIONS
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – PERIPHERAL /
REGIONAL
NERVE BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SPINAL
ACCESSORY
NERVE BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SUPRASCAPULAR
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – AXILLARY NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – OCCIPITAL NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – INTERCOSTAL
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SCIATIC NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – GENITOFEMORAL
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – ILIOINGUINAL
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SAPHENOUS
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – LATERAL FEMORAL
CUTANEOUS
NERVE BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SUPRAORBITAL
NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – MEDIAN NERVE
BLOCK
INTERVENTIONAL STRATEGIES – SYMPATHETIC
NERVE
BLOCK
RADIOPHARMACEUTICALS
HYALURONAN KNEE INJECTIONS
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – PHYSICAL AND
OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPIES
RETURN TO WORK
HANDICAPPED PARKING
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – TENS UNITS
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – RELIGION
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – PET THERAPY
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – SUPPORT
GROUPS,
DIARIES
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – KYPHOPLASTY
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – MAGNETS
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – ACUPUNCTURE
AND
MASSAGE
MORPHINE INTRATHECAL PUMP IMPLANTATION
SURGICAL MANAGEMENT
SURGICAL MANAGEMENT – OPTIMAL PATIENTS FOR
SURGICAL
REFERRAL
NON-PHARMACOLOGIC TREATMENTS – CHIROPRACTIC
MANIPULATION
SUMMARY – INITIAL TREATMENT STRATEGIES
SUMMARY – SPECIAL POPULATIONS
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
DEFINITION / INTRODUCTION
Pain is defined as a subjective
unpleasant
sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or potential
tissue
damage. Persistent pain is a treatable condition, not unlike
other
medical conditions of hypertension, diabetes, emphysema, and
cancer.
Pain is real. Just as high blood sugar is real and mandates
constant
attention in the diabetic, so too is pain a valid medical condition
that
mandates constant attention. Without constant attention to any
medical
condition, morbidity and mortality ensue. As with diabetes,
hypertension,
and other medical conditions, the generators of pain are dynamic and
evolve
with time, necessitating changes in management.
As with these other medical conditions,
pain
is dynamic in that it evolves with time. Degenerative
osteoarthritis
and postsurgical scarring progress over sequential years with
escalation
in pain intensity. Conversely, myofascial pain and fibromyalgia
may
decrease over time with treatment with progressively decreasing
medication
needs.
Patients must be seen regularly to address
pain
as well as obesity, depression, anxiety, erectile dysfunction, restless
legs syndrome, fatigue, insomnia, and other sequelae of pain in
addition
to obesity, depression, anxiety, and other conditions which contribute
to intensification of pain.
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF PAIN – SCOPE OF THE
CONDITION
Approximately 65 million people in the
U.S.A.
suffer from chronic pain, and the annual prevalence of back pain ranges
from 15%-45%.(34) Of all patients suffereing from acute back
pain,
5% will develop chronic, constant, and disabling pain.(254)
Malignant
and nonmalignant pain is the single most common reason why patients
present
to a physician.( ) Untreated pain results in
unnecessary
suffering, compromised quality of life, impaired work ability, and
enormous
avoidable stresses on the Medicare and Medicaid disability
services.
Inadequate treament of pain is not simply
an
issue of numbers. Untreated pain has been described as a
suicidogen.(248)
Pain may result in some patients committing suicide(13) or request
physicians
to assist them in early death to alleviate the burden, suffering, and
despair
of chronic pain.(10)
There is great satisfaction for the
clinician
who decreases a patient’s pain, enhances their function, and allows
them
to lead a higher quality,( ) more fulfilled life. He who
saves
one life it is as if he saved the world entire.(258,259,260)
Patients whose pain is not treated may
pursue
self-treatment, often with dangerous consequences given their
limitations
in medical knowledge. Acetaminophen has been reported as the
second
leading cause of toxic drug ingestion in the U.S.A., and a portion of
these
deaths were related to accidental poisoning in an attempt to relieve
pain.(17)
Other patients pursue illegal drugs such as alcohol, heroine, or
cocaine
for symptomatic relief when deprived of access to pain
management.
It is not true that nobody dies because of pain. In
contra-distinction
to practitioners who lack fundamental knowledge of pain management, the
clear answer to chronic pain is not premature death but treatment with
a higher, more productive quality of life.
CLASSIFICATION OF PAIN
Pain can be classified in several different
ways.
In terms of duration since time of onset, pain can be acute or
chronic.
Acute pain serves a critical biologic function to alert people to
address
pathology such as fracture or laceration. Chronic pain may alert
the patient to limit heavy lifting exertion to delay the progression of
knee cartilage degradation, for example, but chronic pain often serves
no valuable physiologic function. The distinction is of value as
acute pain is often curable with nonsteroid anti-inflammatories,
sympathetic
plexus blockade, and definitive surgery. Subacute pain persists
for
1-3 months and this is the vestige of the “therapeutic window” during
which
time it is important to be aggressive as once this window closes it is
much more difficult to cure pain. Chronic pain is present for
approximately
three months and though cure is occasionally possible, the primary
goals
change to decreasing pain intensity, increasing function with possible
return to work, and improving quality of life. Chronic pain often
is accompanied by mood depression and other treatable
comorbidities.
Pain can be also classified in terms of the
perpetuating
mechanism, either mechanical, neuropathic, or visceral.
Mechanical
pain is often referred to as nociceptive pain and includes arthritis,
disc
herniation, myofascial, fractures, and other pathologic entities.
Neuropathic pain diagnoses include thalamic pain, reflex sympathetic
dystrophy,
post-herpetic neuralgia, and other conditions. Visceral pain may
include the pain experienced from hollow organ distension as with
constipation
or urinary retention. The distinction between classifications is
important in terms of selecting medications most likely to be
efficacious.
For example, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories are not overwhelmingly
helpful
in the management of neuropathic pain whereas systemic anti-arrhythmic
agents are rarely warranted in the treatment of mechanical pain.
Similarly, high dose opioids are rarely the foundation of care in the
successful
and most reasonable management of neuropathic pain. Visceral
bladder
pain is often responsive to cimetidine.( ) Visceral
pain
may also respond to smooth muscle relaxants, including the opioids as
well
as peripheral alpha antagonists.
PAIN MANAGEMENT TREATMENT GOALS
The goal of treatment of chronic pain is
not
the elimination of pain, as this is not often possible. The goals
of pain management include reduction in pain with consequent
enhancement
of quality of life as well as improved function, often with return to
work.
Patients suffering in pain experience pain “taking over” their
lives.
Pain is virtually integrated into “who they are” in terms of how they
view
themselves. It is impossible for those of us without pain to
fully
relate, but we must have compassion. They have to weigh every
potential
act to decide if it may exacerbate their pain and limit function for
days.
Decreasing their pain allows them to live a more normal life.
Physicians
must live the Golden Rule of “Do unto others as you wish done onto you”
to mandate helping those in pain as the physician would wish if he had
pain. Conversely, the Golden Rule “Do not do onto others as you
would
not have done onto you” mandates not withholding pain management to
those
who are suffering.
In type II diabetics increased walking
frequency
as well as increased pace of walking decreased cardiovascular
mortality.(2)
Reduction in pain frequently increases patient walking and exertional
levels.
Suprascapular nerve block may allow patients with severe gleno-humeral
arthritis to feed themselves, comb their hair, and perform other simple
tasks (112) that most of the world takes for granted.
MECHANISMS OF PAIN – PHYSIOLOGY
Normally, the action potential is generated
at
the peripheral nociceptor at the site of inflammation in acute pain.
The
action potential consists of an initial rapid voltage ion channel gated
depolarization as positively charged sodium ions enter the cell, making
it less negative. The subsequent slow continued influx of
positively
charged calcium ions keeps the cell depolarized, and the efflux of
potassium
positively charged ions returns the cell to its depolarized
state.
The signal is perpetuated down the length of the axon to the
pre-synaptic
terminal of the dorsal horn “pain command center” of the segmental
spinal
cord where voltage sensitive ion channels open and close with summation
determining if neurotransmitter is released from the pre-synaptic axon
terminal into the synaptic cleft. Calcium influx at the
pre-synaptic
terminal is a potent force determining if neurotransmitter is released
into the synaptic cleft.
Action potentials must also be generated at
the
peripheral nociceptor before the signal is sent to the spinal cord,
explaining
the efficacy of peripherally active medications such as nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatories.
In the dorsal horn, convergence of
terminals
summation of afferent nociceptive axons from the peripheral nociceptor,
segmental spinal cord modulating interneurons, and axons descending
from
the brain determine if a signal of pain is passed on to the brain to
consciously
interpret the pain signal or if the signal of pain is extinguished at
the
spinal cord level. Synaptic release of inhibitory and excitatory
neurotransmitters opens and closes neurotransmitter dependent cell
membrane
sodium, calcium, and potassium ion channels to allow these positively
charged
ions to enter and exit from the dorsal horn cell. Other ion
channels
are voltage dependent, opening and closing in response to
voltage.
Temporal and spatial summation of all
positive
and negative ion charges at the second order neuron at the dorsal horn
determines if the net effect depolarizes the resting cell membrane
–90mV
charge inside the cell sufficiently more positive to reach the –60mV
threshold.
If threshold is achieved then the all or none action potential is
generated
with synaptic release of neurotransmitters by the dorsal horn to
activate
the post-synaptic neuron with transmission of an afferent nociceptive
signal
to the brain.
Conversely, depolarization with nociception
transmitted
to the brain can be prevented by medications which make the cytosol
more
negative than –90mV by blocking sodium, calcium, and potassium ion
channels.
The cell can also be made refractory to action potential generation by
medications which enhance GABA and other inhibitory neurotransmitters
such
as zonisamide (Zonegran), tiagabine (Gabitril), topiramide (Topamax),
and
gabapentin (Neurontin) or decrease release of excitatory
neurotransmitters
such as glutamate, substance P, kinins, and histamine such as H1 and H2
receptor antihistamines. Noradrenergic reuptake inhibitors
increase
the duration of time that noradrenaline spends in proximity to the
post-synaptic
membrane of the dorsal horn cell to decrease pain. The cell can
also
be made more refractory to depolarization through the use of
medications
which block the positive influx of charge such as calcium channel
blockade
with the zonisamide (Zonegran), aminoglycocide Neomycin, magnesium,
Ziconotide,
and nifedipine (Adalat, Procardia), verapamil (Calan, Covera, Isoptin,
Tarka, Veralan), diltiazem (Cardizem, Dilacor, Tiazac).
The brain itself may reduce pain.
Thalamic
and limbic brain modulation of the signal may intensify or attenuate
pain
as evidenced by the efficacy of anti-anxiety medications.
Descending
noradrenergic and serotonergic signals from the brain to the dorsal
horn
of the spinal cord may decrease pain.
Mechanisms of pain reduction may be via
decreasing
inflammation, opioid mediated agonism at mu receptors, antidepressant
increases
in serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine neurotransmitters,
anticonvulsant
and anti-arrhythmic blockade of sodium and calcium channels and GABA
agonism,
and other means discussed in this review. Anatomic sites of
action
may include the peripheral nocicepting pain sensor, the segmental
spinal
cord, the dorsal horn, descending pathways from the brain to the dorsal
horn, and the cerebral cortex itself. Dorsal horn processing is
the
unifying basic science theme with respect to the brain receiving the
signal
to perceive pain and then translate that into innocuous or consuming
levels
of pain, suffering, and disability. Given the unifying basic
theme
of modulating sodium, calcium, and potassium ion fluxes to regulate the
action potential nociceptive signal to the brain, it is extremely
difficult
to appreciate any honest patient’s contention that only narcotics
effectively
decrease pain.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGIC MECHANISMS OF ACUTE AND
CHRONIC
PAIN
Acute pain occurred co-incident with injury
and
lasts for less than a month. Acute pain has the greatest
likelihood
of response to treatment. It is discussed as always being
physiologic,
but this is not the case in various situations of neuropathic pain such
as reflex sympathetic dystrophy, thalamic pain, and other conditions in
which the presence of pain does not alert the individual to an ongoing
correctable source of tissue damage. Subacute pain occurs between
one to three months post-injury and this is referred to as the
“therapeutic
window” period during which aggressive treatment may still effect full
resolution of mechanical and neuropathic pain in most patients.
Chronic
pain has been described as maladaptive with no ongoing tissue
damage.
This is usually but not universally true. Chronic pain is felt in
some cases to be normal as physiologically mediated by protracted
inflammation
as with rheumatoid arthritis. However, most cases of chronic pain
are not mediated by ongoing inflammation, but rather by a maladaptive
hyperexcitable
peripheral and central nervous system.
In the periphery, the extrafusal muscle may
be
in varying degrees of perpetual spasm as with myofascial pain and
fibromyalgia.
The intrafusal fiber may be at constant high tone as mediated by
efferent
A-gamma fibers from a similarly hyperaroused segmental spinal
cord.
The peripheral nociceptor of the skin may
be
sensitized to otherwise innocuous subthreshoold stimuli such as light
touch
which now result in a volley of action potentials transmitted to the
presynaptic
terminal. The constant exposure to inflammatory mediators such as
with burns may mediate this condition.( )
The damaged peripheral nerve from traction,
compression,
transsection, or demyelination with exposure of the unprotected axon
may
fire spontaneous ectopic discharge to the dorsal horn. The
damaged
axon may result in spontaneous depolarization of adjacent axons by
ephaptic
transmission with signals sent to the brain in the absence of
pain.
The constant volleys of spontaneous discharges may create and maintain
a central state of sensitization / wind-up / hyperexcitability(243) in
the dorsal horn with the cell less negative and closer to threshhold to
send an action potential to the brain.
In the central nervous system, the dorsal
horn
wide dynamic range neuron is also sensitized and hyperexcitable such
that
it is more likely to discharge an action potential to send a
nociceptive
signal to the brain. The wide dynamic range neuron of the dorsal horn
becomes
less discriminate in terms of responding to afferent pain and light
touch
impulses. This results in normal non-painful stimuli resulting in
allodynia profound pain and mildly painful stimuli resulting in
hyperalgesia.(243)
The afferent C and A-delta fiber from the periphery is more likely to
generate
a reflex response by the hyperexcited anterior horn cell to tell the
muscle
to contract and spasm. The effect of anxiety to increase
descending
sympathetic tone may also activate peripheral mechanoreceptors whose
afferents
converge on the sensitized wide dynamic range neurons to prompt an
ascending
discharge to the brain.(218)
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – CALCIUM
CHANNELS
Calcium is important in the
generation
of the action potential at the dendrite to transmit the nociception to
the pre-synaptic terminal axon as mediated by slow influx of calcium
after
the initial rapid sodium influx. In addition, calcium influx at
the
axon of the pre-synaptic terminal in response to the voltage from the
action
potential results in exocytosis neurotransmitter vesicles to the
synaptic
cleft to activate or suppress the post-synaptic cell membrane.
Medications which impair calcium influx
into
neurons at the nerve terminal at the pre-synaptic membrane will
decrease
the likelihood that the cell will release nociceptive glutamate
neurotransmitter
vesicles into the synaptic cleft to reach the post-synaptic
membrane(246)
such that the peripheral nociceptive signal does not get transmitted
beyond
that level to reach the brain for conscious perception of pain and
interpretation
into varying degrees of suffering.
Scientists have identified three main
pathways
for calcium influx into the neuron, include voltage opening of channels
in response to depolarization, ligand gated nonspecific calcium
channels,
and receptor activated calcium channels.(26) The calcium channel
consists is genetically coded by different genes. Six classes of
voltage activated calcium channels include low threshold T-subtype as
well
as high threshhold L-, N-, P/Q-, and R-subtypes.(253) Different
isoform
subtypes of each channel also exist as proven with N-type channels with
different ease of activation kinetics.(232) Calcium channels of the
P/Q-,
N-, and R- type control glutamate neurotransmitter release.(58)
L-,
N-, and P/Q calcium channels are presented in the dorsal horn, N-
subtype
channels are concentrated in the presynaptic terminals of primary
nociceptive
afferents of the superficial laminae I and II of the dorsal horn, L-
subtype
channels are present in proximal dendrites and cellular bodies in the
central
nervous system and in some glutamate synapses.(26)
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – CALCIUM
CHANNEL BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
Opioids bind to mu, delta, and kappa
opioid
receptors which activates different inhibitory G proteins which inhibit
adenyl cyclase which decreases transmembrane L-, N,- and P/Q- channel
subtype
mediated influx of calcium ions.(26) Opioid kappa receptor
analgesia
may also be mediated by shortening of calcium action potentials without
any change in resting membrane potential such that calcium channel
antagonists
may act differently with respect to mu and delta opioid
receptors.(26)
Supraspinal morphine activates
descending
pathways via serotonin (via intraspinal enkephalin or dynorphin) and
noradrenaline
(directly or via intraspinal acetylcholine) neurotransmitters to act on
the dorsal horn to prevent afferent nociception.(26)
G-protein is a membrane bound subunit which
modulates
N-subtype and P/Q-subtype channels and aminoglycosides block N-subtype
and P/Q subtypes.(26) N-type calcium channel blockers are useful
in the management of severe(245) and chronic(244) pain. Topical
N-type
calcium channel blockers have been demonstrated in basic science
studies
to reduce pain after nerve injury.(243) The aminoglycoside
neomycin
has been demonstrated to decrease both phasic as well as incisional
pain.(246)
The N-channel blocker delivered as topical neomycin decreases pain
following
nerve injury and may interfere with initiation of sensitization of
dorsal
horn neurons.(247) The N-type calcium channel blocker Ziconotide
confers one thousand times the analgesic potency of
morphine.(
) Topical neomycin should also be considered as an option to
reduce
pain in burn injury and topical ulcers if systemic absorption is not
felt
to compromise renal function. In one study topical application of
bacitracin did not confer analgesic benefit(247) and may be
sufficiently
structurally different from gentamicin, streptomycin, and neomycin
related
analgesia(246) or it may be an individual histochemical uniqueness just
as some individuals appreciate relief from one antidepressant, opioid,
anticonvulsant, or skeletal muscle relaxant and not another medication
of the same class but different molecular structure.
Aminoglycoside antibiotics decrease
presynaptic
release of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction and higher doses
block postjunctional acetylcholine receptors, and this must be
considered
in nociceptive interaction as well as aminoglcoside related inhition of
phospholipase C.(246)
Synergistic potentiation between L-type and
T-type
blockers at spinal mu opioid receptors but not at delta and kappa
receptors
has been described.(73) Zonisemide (Zonegran) is a T-type calcium
channel blocker. Ziconotide is undergoing success in FDA trials
as
an N/T calcium channel blocker which has been described as having 1000
times the analgesic potency of morphine.( )
In contra-distinction to antinociception
with
N-subtype blockade, analgesia with the L-subtype channel antagonist
verapamil
(Calan, Covera, Isoptin, Tarka, Veralan) is felt to be via agonism at
mu,
delta, and kappa-3 opioid receptor subtypes.(26) The L-subtype
channel
antagonist nifedipine (Adalat, Procardia) may potentiate morphine
induced
analgesia although it lacked analgesia itself when given in isolation
in
one report.(63) Nifedipine also has efficacy to decrease the
opioid
induced hyperalgesia with may accompany high doses of morphine via NMDA
activation by the biometabolite morphine-3-glucuronide.(11) Oral
nifedipine may also decrease pain related to reflex sympathetic
dystrophy.(49)
Basic science studies also support the efficacy of L-type antagonists
in
opioid potentiation.(246) Diltiazem (Cardizem, Dilacor, Tiazac)
has
also been discussed as an L-type calcium channel blocker.(
)
Magnesium blocks calcium pores(26,246) as
well
as NMDA receptors(246) both of which are mechanisms to decrease
pain.
Patients with severe refractory pain, systemic malabsorption, and
inadequate
diets should be assessed for hypomagnesiumemia. Consideration for
emperic prescription of a multi-vitamin should be entertained.
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – SODIUM CHANNELS
The action potential consists of an initial
rapid
voltage ion channel gated depolarization as positively charged sodium
ions
enter the cell, making it less negative. The subsequent slow
continued
influx of positively charged calcium ions keeps the cell depolarized,
and
the efflux of potassium positively charged ions returns the cell to its
depolarized state.
Temporal and spatial summation of all
positive
and negative ion charges at the second order neuron at the dorsal horn
determines if the net effect depolarizes the resting cell membrane
–90mV
charge inside the cell sufficiently more positive to reach the –60mV
threshold.
If threshold is achieved then the all or none action potential is
generated
with synaptic release of neurotransmitters by the dorsal horn to
activate
the post-synaptic neuron with transmission of an afferent nociceptive
signal
to the brain.
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – SODIUM CHANNEL
BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
Local anesthetics exert their
activity
by temporarily blocking sodium channels to impair action potential
regeneration
and accompanying transmission of pain sensations to the brain.
It is felt that the mechanism of analgesic
action
of opioids is by blocking neuron excitability by depression of sodium
conductance
and increase membrane potassium conductance(23) or by blocking the
opening
of voltage-sensitive calcium channels with a conseuqent decreased
pre-synaptic
release of excitatory neurotransmitters and decreased afferent
transmission
of nociceptive impulses.(23, 26)
Lidocaine patch and crushed propoxyphene
(Darvocet)
topically block sodium channels to block afferent transmission of pain
by preventing action potential generation at the nociceptor as well as
attenuating conduction of pain along the length of the axon.
Zonisamide
(Zonegran) and other anticonvulsants which stabilize sodium flux may
similarly
decrease pain.
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – POTASSIUM
CHANNELS
The action potential consists of an initial
rapid
voltage ion channel gated depolarization as positively charged sodium
ions
enter the cell, making it less negative. The subsequent slow
continued
influx of positively charged calcium ions keeps the cell depolarized,
and
the efflux of potassium positively charged ions returns the cell to its
depolarized state.
Antihistamine mediated
antinociception
transduction has been demonstrated as requiring potassium-ATP and
calcium
gated potassium channels contrary to voltage gated potassium channel
Kv1.1.(186)
MECHANISMS – PHYSIOLOGY – POTASSIUM
CHANNEL BLOCKING
ANALGESICS
Facilitating efflux of potassium will more
promptly
return the depolarized neuron to the resting membrane state of
inactivity.
Efflux of potassium positive charge at rest will also make the cytosol
more negative such that it is less likely to depolarize unless the
stimulus
intensity if overwhelming. This may mediate attenuation of
response in allodynia, decreased response in hyperalgesia, and a more
normal
response to a valid nociceptive stimulus.
GABA-B receptor agonism by lioresal
(Baclofen)
may result in potassium channel mediated hyperpolarization of the alpha
motoneuron.
The mechanism of analgesic action of
opioids
is by blocking neuron excitability by depression of sodium
conductance.(23)
MEASUREMENT OF PAIN
Pain intensity can be measured quite
quickly
and productively with a 0-10 point scale with zero fixed as “no pain”
and
10 fixed as “the most severe amputation intensity level pain that you
can
imagine.” Several people with identical objectively
assessed
pathology may have quite different complaints of pain severity as
assessed
on a 0-10 point scale. Similarly, patients with identical levels
of pain may have different levels of perceived ability to function and
work. The value of the scale, therefore, is to assess a single
patient
over time with respect to improvement with treatment. In
addition,
the patient who always indicates that his pain is 10 out of 10 may have
comorbid or primary mood depression and the pain will not remit without
addressing the depression. Emotional and physiological factors
influence
perception of pain.
The character of pain should also be
assessed
as this often strongly supports a clinical diagnosis and more
individualized
treatment. Complaints of burning character pain suggests a
diagnosis
of reflex sympathetic dystrophy. Dull, throbbing, and aching pain
supports a diagnosis of osteoarthritis, myofascial pain, and
fibromyalgia.
Electric, tingling, and numb quality of pain may suggest radiculopathy,
plexopathy, polyneuropathy, compressive mononeuropathies such as carpal
tunnel syndrome, and intracranial pathology such as thalamic pain,
multiple
sclerosis, and other conditions. Cramping suggests visceral pain
such as the constipation that not uncommonly results from prescription
of opioids or anticholinergic antidepressants without concomitant
treatment
of medication induced intestinal hypomotility. Patients who deny
mood depression but describe their pain as suffering, miserable,
depressing,
or tiring may have atypical depression with pain highly responsive to
antidepressants
or anxiolytics.
DIAGNOSIS
The value of defining a precise
diagnosis
is to identify a strategic target to treat.
As with all branches in the practice of
medicine,
the clinician should always reserve the diagnosis of “idiopathic” after
a reasonable and appropriate diagnostic investigation has
concluded.
“Low back pain” is a symptom, not a diagnosis. Defining a precise
diagnosis can direct specific treatment. To this end, the
clinician
must always review the extent of the diagnostic workup.
Metastatic
testicular pain may disseminate via the retroperitoneum to result in
back
pain. Multiple myeloma must be considered in the workup of back
pain.
Back pain with hematuria must alert the clinician to consider CT-scan
to
assess for renal cell carcinoma. Back pain with testicular mass
suggests
testicular cancer with retroperitoneal extension. EMG and nerve
conduction
studies may indicate active ongoing pathophysiologic axonal denervation
related to anatomic disc herniations on MRI to warrant referral to an
anestheseologist
for epidural injections versus reassurance that the disc herniation is
old and not actively damaging neural tissue. A triple phase bone
scan may confirm an equivocal case of reflex sympathetic dystrophy to
spur
prompt referral for sympathetic nerve blockade.
Renal, testicular, and other
malignancies
may present with back pain. Metastatic tumors should always be
considered
in patients aged fifty years or greater as well as those with family
histories
of malignancy or personal history of smoking or other pro-malignant
risk
factors.
EMERGENCIES
Emergencies in pain mangement include
compartment
syndrome in which direct trauma to tissue may raise pressure in tissues
bounded by tight fascial constraints with risks for compromise of
arterial
perfusion and tissue ischemia. Acute embolic arterial events from
the aortic arch and cardiac chambers may result in acute ischemia and
profound
limb pain. Infectious conditions may result in sepsis.
Gouty
arthropathy may rapidly mutilate tissues. Guillain-Barre syndrome
may present with back pain with rapid progression to compromise muscles
of ventilation. Dissecting abdominal aortic aneurysm may result
in
back pain prior to vascular collapse. Tumor mass, epidural
hematoma,
or intervertebral disc herniation which compresses the central canal
spinal
cord or lower motor neuron cauda equina may result in irreversible
paraplegia
and urinary and fecal incontinence if not promptly neurosurgically
decompressed.
The classic triad of cauda equina syndrome symptoms include urinary
and/or
fecal incontinence, lower extremity weakness, and saddle
anesthesia.
Cauda equina syndrome must be surgically reversed within 48 hours to
preserve
neurologic function.(110) Epidural tumors must be emergently
debulked
and radiated to avoid paraplegia. If reflex sympathetic dystrophy
is not treated aggressively within the first few months of onset, then
it is much more likely to become disabling for ensuing
decades.
The natural history of disc
herniations
are to recede spontaneously with activity modification. Pain may
persist as the subsequently degenerated and dehydrated disc
suboptimally
cushions the vertebral bodies with pain generated from the ?highly
innervated
periosteum of the vertebrae.
Abdominal aortic aneurysm,
nephrolithiasis,
disc space infection, Guillain-Barre Syndrome may also present with
back
pain.
TREATMENT OF PAIN
Maximal success in the treatment of pain
characteristically
requires multimodal management. This limits dose related side
effects
and also takes advantage of addressing pain not only through different
pharmacologic mechanisms of action but also at different anatomic
sites.
Though oral, topical, insufflated, and injected medications are
powerful
adjuncts, behavioral modifications, psychologic coping strategies,
adaptive
equipment, physical modalities, learning an independent exercise
program,
and definitive surgical treatment are fundamental to comprehensive
care.
Comprehensive treatment must also include treatment of comorbid
conditions
that are commonly present in the chronic pain population. The
clinician
must also be prepared to address the common side effects of analgesics.
COMORBID CONDITIONS
Comprehensive pain management includes the
treatment
of comorbid conditions such as mood depression, chronic fatigue,
secondary
myofascial pain, anxiety disorder, insomnia, restless legs syndrome,
xerostomia,
orthostatic hypotension, and erectile dysfunction. Treating these
comorbid conditions may result in decreased pain intensity with
decreased
analgesic prescription requirements. If patients are appreciating
analgesia with a particular medication, then onset of side effects does
not mandate discontinuation of the precipitant is the comorbid
condition
can be treated. A finite number of analgesics exists, and if the
side effect is safely treated then the analgesic should be continued.
COMORBID CONDITIONS – MOOD DEPRESSION
It is unfortunate that many people do
not
recognize mood depression as simply another medical condition to be
treated.
Depression is present in % of patients with chronic
pain.(
) Pain causes mood depression,( ) and worsening of
depression
will increase pain in a cascading cycle that may result in patient
death
by suicide. After family and friends, the first professional
contact
of depressed patients is a nonpsychiatric physician, not a psychiatrist
or minister.(175) As such, given the higher comorbidity between
mood
depression and chronic pain, the pain management physician must make it
office protocol to discuss issues of mood depression and anxiety with
chronic
pain patients on regular follow-ups. The physician striving
towards
comprehensive pain management should be aware of the fact “If you don’t
ask [the patient about mood depression] then you don’t know.”
Classic treatment of mood depression
involves
serotonergic and / or tricyclic antidepressants. Synergistic care
may be afforded with provigil, methylphenidate, psychologic
counselling,
and interventions such as electroconvulsive therapies.
Provigil (Modafinil) is a novel
psychostimulant
with efficacy to address chronic fatigue without the diversion related
concerns of methylphenidate. It has synergistic efficacy with
SSRI
antidepressants to address depression.(
)
Methylphenidate (Ritalin) is a
narcotic
psychostimulant with noradrenergic and dopaminergic properties.
It
is well tolerated, even in the elderly. However, important
criminal
diversion related issues are discussed below in the psychostimulant
section
of this review.
Psychologists expert in pain
management
do more than simply teach pain coping strategies. They also
assist
the patient in dealing with contributory mood depression and anxiety
disorders.
A competent psychologist will not hesitate to refer patients for
pharmacologic
treatment, and an expert psychologist will be familiar with the
considerable
adverse consequences of prescribing benzodiazepines.
Psychiatrists will often investigate
whether
the patient has been noncompliant with antidepressants and ingested
them
for too short a period of time to truly warrant documentation of
inefficacy.
The psychiatric expert may also escalate the dose to an extent greater
than that which the pain management clinician is comfortable.
Psychiatrists
may also feel comfortable utilizing medications such as monoamine
oxidase
inhibitors with accompanying restrictions in terms of potential
toxicity.
Psychiatrists also may discuss electroconvulsive therapy and other
treatment
options.
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a safe
and
highly efficacious treatment to address mood depression that is
refractory
to oral pharmacologic intervention.( ) Patients should be
educated
as to the safety of ECT, and that successful treatment of pain is
commonly
hindered by refractory pain induced depression. Electroconvulsive
therapy has been described as successfully decreasing chronic
pain.(
)
COMORBID CONDITIONS – ANXIETY
Pain is as a subjective unpleasant sensory
and
emotional experience associated with actual or potential tissue
damage.
The very nature of the worldwide acceptance of this definition declares
that anxiety is inherent to pain interpretation and processing.
As
such, anxiety may be the emotional reactivity response to pain.
The
manner in which pain may create anxiety disorder can be appreciated by
the fact that the cerebral cortex responds to the dyshomeostasis of
pain
by increasing sympathetic outflow to limbic structures to result in
anxiety.(
)
Anxiety increased pain is particularly
common
in patients with painful conditions such as multiple sclerosis,
rheumatoid
arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosis, comorbid mental illness,
cancer,
and other conditions with unpredictable waxes and wanes in disease
progression.
Even in the absence of these conditions, anxiety is often present by
the
unpredictable nature of day to day barometric pressure fluctuation
effects
on pain( ) as well as concerns regarding not knowing if
mildly
increased exertion will precipitate major flairs in pain.
In a cyclic pattern, pain precipitates
anxiety
and anxiety may increase pain intensity( ) which can in turn
increase
anxiety which can increase pain.
Given the higher comorbidity between
anxiety
and chronic pain, the pain management physician must make it office
protocol
to discuss issues of mood depression and anxiety with chronic pain
patients
on regular follow-ups. Anxiety is of central importance for
coping
with chronic pain,(195) and this must constantly be addressed by the
clinician
to avoid escalations in pain with functional decompensation. A
component
of every patient’s follow-up should encompass identifying and
addressing
stress related events as opposed to a reflex increase in patient’s
opioid
and nonopioid analgesic dose.
Resolution of stress related to pending
litigation
may decrease pain.(254)
The importance of treating anxiety and not
allowing
acute pain to persist untreated cannot be overemphasized.
Transformation
of acute to chronic pain is related to the duration as well as the
intensity
of pain as well as factors such as anxiety which enormously increase
pain
intensity and distribution. This clearly implies that withholding
all forms of pain management will predispose to entrenchment of pain to
the chronic state as well as broadening the scope of suffering and
disability.
In no way is this to mean that the clinician is ever compelled to
utilize
opioids as many nonopioid analgesics effect antinociception via the
same
secondary molecular mediators.
Psychologists expert in pain management do
more
than simply teach pain coping strategies. They also assist the
patient
in dealing with contributory mood depression and anxiety
disorders.
A competent psychologist will not hesitate to refer patients for
pharmacologic
treatment, and an expert psychologist will be familiar with the
considerable
adverse consequences of prescribing benzodiazepines.
The clinician should not hesitate to refer
patients
to psychologists who specialize in pain management as these experts may
be extremely helpful to teach patients coping strategies through
biofeedback,
self hypnosis, visual imagery, deep breathing, and other coping
strategies.
Some authors have reported that pain may
decrease
in some patients following settlement of trauma related litigation as
the
accompanying anxiety remits following mental closure of the adversarial
process.(160) This is not surprising given the known anatomic
relationship
between the emotional centers of the limbic system and pain
processing.
Conversely, patients who master relaxation techniques may attenuate
pain
such that less potent analgesics are required.
Patients should be encouraged to
participate
in regular aerobic exercise as well as consider learning yoga and
meditation
skills to treat anxiety.
Anxiety may be a side effect of
certain
noradrenergic analgesics, including bupropion (Wellbutrin, Zyban),(5)
methylphenidate
(Ritalin), atomoxetine (Strattera) and high doses of modafinil
(Provigil).
Seratonin agonists are often used to
decrease
anxiety disorders.
GABA-B receptor agonists decrease
anxiety
disorders( ) without the considerable complications of
benzodiazepines.
GABA agonists are also valuable to decrease pain via brain stem
originating
descending inhibitory pathways to the dorsal horn(70) such that less
afferent
pain signal to the cerebral cortex is transmitted. Lioresal
(Baclofen)
is discussed under “muscle relaxants” in this article. It is
generically
available and not cost prohibitive. Zonisamide (Zonegran),
Tiagabine
(Gabitril), and gabapentin (Neurontin) are GABA anticonvulsants
discussed
below with potent anxiolytic properties.
The analagesic piperazine
antihistamine
hydroxyzine (Atarax, Vistaril) may also decrease anxiety.
Buspirone (Buspar) may also decrease
anxiety,
although the first few weeks of its use may initially increase anxiety,
limiting patient compliance.
Zyprexa (Olanzapine) is an anxiolytic
and
mood stabilizer which has been successfully utilized to treat even
severe
cancer related pain associated with anxiety.(39)
Benzodiazepines are discussed below
under
“muscle relaxants” and are contra-indicated in the management of
chronic
pain.
COMORBID CONDITIONS – OBESITY
Patients who are in pain are often less
active
and the decreased caloric expenditure commonly results in obesity as a
sequelae of pain. In a cyclic pattern patients who are obese
often
suffer greater back,( ) hip,( ), knee,( ) and ankle
and
foot pain.( ) In a cyclic pattern pain leads to obesity
which
leads to greater pain and so forth. It has been known for some
time
that “…osteoarthritis occur[s] more in obese people.”(20) The
corollary
to this, of course, is that loss of weight will delay the manifestation
and progression of osteoarthritis with its accompanying pain and
dysfunction.
Medical intervention of
osteoarthritis
includes treatment of obesity via weight reduction as being overweight
is a major risk factor for osteoarthritis.(1)
Patients with back pain should be taught
the
application of the physics formula “torque = force times
distance.”
This equation indicates that the torque required to be generated by the
paraspinals is increased as the distance from the spine axis of
rotation
is increased. If the patient is taught to carry objects closer to
the chest wall and spine as opposed to carrying them with the shoulders
flexed and elbows extended, then the torque generated by the paraspinal
extensors is less with less fatigue, strain, and pain of these
tissues.
Similarly, obese patients that lose weight will suffer less back pain
as
the abdominal girth recedes and the distance from the spine
diminishes.
Also, force is mass times gravity. As such, as the obese patient
loses mass, the force is reduced as is the torque required to be
exerted
by the paraspinals to maintain the erect posture. Another
mechanism
by which obesity increases back pain is by obesity in the thorax
resulting
in increased weight and axial pressure on the lumbar discs.
Obesity increases forces magnified through
the
hips, knees, ankles, and feet, and assisting patients to lose weight
will
decrease pain at these sites. During walking the knees absorb
300-400%
of body weight.( ) As such, it is not surprising that
obesity
exponentially contributes to knee pain.(61) During deep knee bend
the patellofemoral joint is exposed to a load 900%-1000% of body
weight.(
) As the superficial erector spinae iliocostalis and longissimus
as well as the transversospinalis first deep layer transvers large
spinal
segments, connecting cervicothoracic and thoracolumbar paraspinals, it
is understandable that decreasing stress on lumbar paraspinals through
weight loss will decrease thoracic and cervical paraspinal stress with
consequent decreased mid-back as well as decreased neck pain with
weight
loss.( )
Treatment of obesity must include education
regarding
limitation of caloric intake, particularly of fats and carbohydrates as
well as increased energy expenditure through exercise. Patients
with
physical findings to suggest thyroid hypofunction may also require
testing.
Pharmacologic management does not constitute a replacement of
behavioral
modification in terms of increased aerobic exercise and dietary
adjustments.
Substitution for medications such as amitriptyline (Elavil),
mirtazapine
(Remeron), paroxetine (Paxil) and zyprexa (Olanzapine) which result in
weight gain should be considered.
COMORBID OBESITY – TREATMENT – IMPAIRING
FAT ABSORPTION
Orlistat (Xenical) may be prescribed to
decrease
pain via promoting weight loss with the added health benefit of
decreasing
fat absorption. An additional benefit of orlistat includes
decreasing
risks for atherosclerotic events of stroke and myocardial
infarction.
It may also be quite helpful to treat diabetes by improving blood
sugars
and insulin responsiveness by decreasing central adiposity.( )
Orlistat should be considered synergistic
treatment
with medications which suppress appetite. Though it is still not
covered by many prescription plans, at $1/pill, thirty meals a month
for
$30 is similar to the copay of most medications that are covered by
insurance
plans.
COMORBID OBESITY – TREATMENT –
SUPPRESSING APPETITE
Zonisemide (Zonegran) is an analgesic
anticonvulsant
that has been demonstrated in a randomized, double-blind,
placebo-controlled
trail to result in significantly greater weight loss when combined with
a hypocaloric diet compared to dietary intervention alone.(200)
Though
the precise mechanism(s) by which appetite suppression with zonisemide
occurs, severe have been forwarded, including increase in serotonin
release,
enhanced dopamine synthesis, and dopamine-2 subtype receptor
stimulation.(200)
In addition, zonisemide is a carbonic anhydrase inhibitor and may make
carbonated beverages taste bitter and less likely to be consumed.
Topiramate (Topamax) is a carbonic
anhydrase
inhibitor and may make carbonated beverages taste bitter and less
likely
to be consumed.
Bupropion (Wellbutrin SR, Zyban) may
decrease
appetite to facilitate weight loss.(5,88,89) This medication may
treat comorbid pain, mood depression, and tobacco craving.
Venlafaxine (Effexor) is an analgesic
antidepressant
which not uncommonly precipitates anorexia.
As a controlled substance, methylphenidate
should
not be prescribed for the indication of weight loss, but combined with
comorbid refractory mood depression and severe pain, anorexia may be an
efficacious side effect.
As with all over the counter products
free
of close FDA and FTC scrutiny, patients should be aware that ephedra
weight
loss supplement has serious cardiovascular and cognitive toxic effects
including stroke and psychosis, and that adverse effects occur in
20%-60%
of patients.(116)
COMORBID CONDITIONS – MYOFASCIAL PAIN /
FIBROMYALGIA
Myalgias precipitated by manual palpation
is
termed myofascial pain. Fibromyalgia is diffuse myofascial pain
of
the neck, shoulders, and lower back. Although myofascial pain may
be a primary disorder following direct trauma as with contusions or
following
motor vehicle forceful cervical flexion and extension whiplash
injuries,
it most often is secondary to comorbid pathology. Intervertebral
disc herniation, degenerative osteoarthritis, and other conditions that
establish a cycle of decreased activity with impaired muscle
flexibility
and strength, predisposing to enhanced susceptibility to secondary
muscle
strain. Although most strains heal with rest and nonsterioidal
anti-inflammatories,
some strains persist as chronic pain in the form of myofascial pain and
fibromyalgia. Lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, colitis, Crohn’s
disease,
and other auto-immune conditions in which the body attacks multiple
organ
system may also result in secondary fibromyalgia. Although
anti-Jo
1, CPK, ESR, and other serologic markers for myopathy and vasculitis
are
negative in the workup, the increased frequency of fibromyalgia in
recognized
discrete auto-immune disorders suggests that the etiologic antibody
simply
remains to be identified. The foundation of treatment of
fibromyalgia
is treatment of mood depression if present, addressing insomnia and
chronic
fatigue, trigger point injections, a program of aerobic exercise, and
oral
analgesics to allow the patient a measure of self control. The
use
of opioids in the management of fibromyalgia remains
controversial.
Patients with cervicothoracic
post-traumatic
syrinx may present with diffuse fibromyalgia symptoms. If not
neurosurgically
confirmed to be safe, patients at risk for cephalid progression to
compromise
medullary centers of respiration or caudal extension to compromise anal
sphincter tone and reflexive bladder function. Cervical and upper
back/posterior shoudler pain may result from motor vehicle accident
related
whiplash with traction of the spinal accessory and suprascapular nerves
from the violent head and neck motion. Fibromyalgia is a
diagnosis
of exclusion which cannot be embraced until investigation for other
etiologies
such as syrinx, fracture, nerve traction, auto-immune dysfunction,….
Fibromyalgia is a condition of diffuse pain
as
opposed to regional myofascial pain, and both conditions are associated
with chronic fatigue, insomnia, mood depression, and other
conditions.
Because there exist no objective radiologic findings to confirm a
diagnosis
of primary ideopathic fibromyalgia, many clinicians do not feel as
comfortable
prescribing opioids or higher doses of opioids to such patients. This
is
distinct from the patient with regional myofascial pain who has
comorbid
degenerative arthritis, post-surgical scarring, or other objectively
confirmed
condition. Ideopathic fibromyalgia patients do best with aerobic
exercise, daily flexibility exercises, trigger point / nerve block
injections,
continued working, and treating comorbid mood depression and
insomnia.
As discussed below, the clinician should feel more comfortable with
opioid
prescription if the opioids allow the patient to function by return to
work. Indeed, if modifications in terms of work intensity and
social
acceptance are embraced, 100% of patients with fibromyalgia often
return
to full time work.(160) “Fibromyalgia does not necessarily cause
work disability,” and it has been suggested that this may be achieved
by
“…abolishing disability awards based on the diagnosis of fibromyalgia,”
thereby “…encouraging patients to get better, rather than to see
themselves
as disabled.”(160)
Secondary fibromyalgia patients have
underlying
objectively defined disease. For example, fibromyalgia is more
common
in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), particularly Crohn’s
Disease.(57)
It certainly is not unexpected that patients with auto-immune
conditions
directed against the bowel would also have an as yet unidentified
auto-immune
mediator against muscle tissue just as IBD patients often suffer from
peripheral
arthritis and spondylitis.( ) Similarly, patients with
systemic
lupus erythematosis( ) and patients with rheumatoid
arthritis(
) have higher incidences of fibromyalgia. Patients with clear
histories
of trauma should be considered better candidates for opioids as the
forces
involved in trauma may result in sufficient pathology to induce
localized
myofascial pain and diffuse fibromyalgia,(160) and the pain may persist
for years following the trauma.(160) Regional pain is a
recognized
entity in the absence of trauma in patients who work in repetitive
strain
environments.(160)
COMORBID CONDITIONS – SMOKING TOBACCO
Nicotine of tobacco smoke may
directly
effect vasoconstriction surrounding the intervertebral disc as well as
toxic changes in the discs themselves, including fibrosis and necrosis
of the nucleus pulposus of the discs, cracks and detachment of the
fibrous
ring, and decreased collagen and proteoglycan synthesis in the
disc.(144)
An unhealthy disc is more likely to herniate as well as dessicate with
decreased cushioning between vertebral bodies in the form of
degenerative
disc disease.
Smokers experience more frequent episodes
of
back pain as well as greater intensity of back pain. Multiple
mechanisms
by which this occurs has been suggested.
Smoking predisposes to neck pain.
Smoking predisposes to knee
pain.(61)
Smoking cigarrettes is associated
with
myofascial pain and fibromyalgia.(199)
Physician counceling, support, and
education
can markedly facilitate successful quitting of smoking. Patients
should be presented with a reasonable goal of smoking one less
cigarette
per week or month. Though confrontational approaches succeed much
less frequently than supportive physician mediated intervention,
sometimes
educating a patient that their second hand smoke increases the
likelihood
of amputation, stroke, myocardial infarction, cancers, and death(111)
in
their children and spouse will sufficiently motivate patients to pursue
less dangerous habits.
Bupropion (Wellbutrin SR, Zyban)
increases
dopamine and norepinephrine in the mesolimbic dopaminergic system and
locus
ceruleus of the brain to simulate the reward rush of cigarrette smoking
as well as to lessen withdrawal symptoms to successfully help people
quit
smoking.(5) Patients may require bupropion for up to a year, but
its use may be complicated by insomnia, xerostomia, and
anxiety.(5)
As such, patients should consume this noradrenergic medication early in
the morning to avoid interference with sleep hygiene. Greater
success
with smoking abstention may be achieved with concomitant prescription
of
the nicotine patch relative to unimodal pharmacologic
treatment.(94)
Because the nicotine patch will only be utilized for a short time to
effect
cure of smoking addiction, its negative effects on disc health is
warranted.
COMORBID CONDITIONS – INSOMNIA
Pain may result in insomnia.(7) Pain from
the
dorsal horn of the segmental spinal cord in transmitted up the
spinoreticulothalamic
tract to the hypothalamus. The hypothalamus regulates the
autonomic
function of sleep and this defines a basic science mechanism by which
pain
results in insomnia. In a cyclic pattern, insomnia may increase
pain(
) which may in turn increase insomnia with escalation in pain.
Sleep
disorders may include delayed onset of sleep, frequent awakenings,
decreased
sleep duration, daytime grogginess, and nonrestorative sleep.(7) Poor
sleep
hygiene may increase daytime pain.
Insomnia may be a side effect of
noradrenergic
analgesics, including bupropion (Wellbutrin, Zyban),(5) methylphenidate
(Ritalin), atomoxetine (Strattera) and high doses of modafinil
(Provigil).
Insomnia may be addressed with a multitude
of
agents, including muscle relaxants, mirtazapine (Remeron),
dextromethorphan,
zonisamide (Zonegran), topiramide (Topamax), and other agents.
Tiagabine
(Gabitril) is particularly advantageous in the promotion of sleep as
this
medication enhances the delta component of sleep such that patients
awaken
refreshed.( ) Melatonin is a particularly wise
selection
in the elderly as this population often produces less melatonin than
younger
people as a normal consequence of aging, and exogenous repletion may
counter
this effect and promote restful sleep.( ) Antihistamines
are
often sedating and have potent analgesic properties.(149,179,180)
Desyrel (Trazodone) is an excellent sleep aid in women, even the
elderly,
as it has minimal anticholinergic properties. However, this
medication
is relatively contra-indicated in men as it may result in painful
priapism
with the urological emergent need for decompression with resultant
impotence.(
) Gabapentin (Neurontin) increases REM sleep without increasing
delta
sleep.( )
Benzodiazepines reduce slow wave and REM
sleep.
This class of nonalgesic narcotic is discussed in this review under the
“MUSCLE RELAXANT” section. Tricyclic antidepressants can improve
sleep, but they also may intensify nocturnal myoclonus and restless
legs
syndrome. If tricyclics are utilized nortriptyline (Pamelor) may also
improve
insomnia with far less xerostomia and risk for subsequent periodontitis
and tooth decay relative to the highly anticholinergic agent
amitriptyline
(Elavil). Use of a mild psychostimulant at 8AM may decrease
daytime
fatigue and eliminate naps such that better sleep hygiene is
fostered.
Zaleplon (Sonata) and Zolpidem (Ambien)
have
been FDA approved as “benzodiazepine like” agents, but they have not
been
available for sufficient decades such that data has not yet been
accumulated
to define if they have similar “benzodiazepine like” risks for mood
depression,
rebound insomnia, and rebound anxiety with chronic use. It would
seem that “If it walks like a duck, if it quacks like a duck, then it
is
a duck” may apply to this class of medications marked as
“benzodiazepine-like”
until sufficient postmarketing surveillance studies sufficiently prove
otherwise. As such, they should be prescribed judiciously with
close
monitoring such that only perhaps two tabs are available per week for
patient
consumption with close monitoring in the patient’s chart of number of
tabs
prescribed over time.
Though sedating in many patients, opioids
should
be utilized to treat pain, not escalated progressively to enhance
sleep.
It is foolish to suggest that the only class of medications which
improves
sleep are opioids. If another class of medication induces sleep
then
the unconscious patient will not suffer pain. In addition,
opioids
reduce restorative delta wave sleep such that patients may be more
likely
to awaken in an unrefreshed state.
COMORBID CONDITIONS – RESTLESS LEGS
SYNDROME
Restless legs syndrome (RLS) is a very
disquieting
feeling of needing to move the legs and not feeling comfortable without
doing so. Some clinicians have likened it to the akathisia that
may
be seen in patients with mental illness who receive excessive dopamine
blocking medications.
Tricyclic antidepressants have
anti-cholinergic
properties and may increase RLS as may dopamine blocking
medications.
Substitution of offensive medications may alleviate RLS.
Treatment of RLS may also include the use
of
dopaminergic agonists. Ropinirole (Requip) as well as pramipexole
(Mirapex) are non-ergot dopamine receptor agonists and may decrease
symptoms.
Amantadine (Symmetrel) is a stimulating analgesic dopamine agonist
which
may also decrease RLS. Carbidopa-levodopa (Sinemet) may also help
in the management of RLS.
Gabapentin (Neurontin) is soon to become
generically
available analgesic and may also decrease RLS.(205)
Treatment of RLS may also include the use
of
cholinergic agonists.
COMORBID CONDITIONS – ERECTILE
DYSFUNCTION
Erectile dysfunction is a common
accompaniment
to chronic pain( ) and side effect of some
antidepressants.
After treatable causes are excluded, working with the primary care
physician
to consider sildenafil (Viagra), should be entertained.
The physician striving towards
comprehensive
pain management should be aware of the fact “If you don’t ask [the
patient
about erectile dysfunction] then you don’t know.”
COMORBID CONDITIONS – CHRONIC FATIGUE
Patients with chronic fatigue suffer
debilitating
exhaustion for at least six months that is not relieved by rest nor is
it related to mood depression.(24). Fatigue is distinct from
weakness
as patients lack neurologic weakness in ideopathic fatigue. In
addition,
patients suffering from fatigue can summon full strength if motivated
by
a crisis, unlike the patient with fatigue. Chronic fatigue may be
a primary idiopathic disorder or it may be a medical sequelae such as
viral
or other infection or auto-immune rheumatologic condition.(24)
Fatigue
secondary to insomnia is best addressed by enhancing sleep
hygiene.
Intolerable fatigue may preclude dose advancement with opioids to treat
pain with consequent suboptimal quality of life and unmet functional
capacity.
Chronic pain is etiologically related to
fatigue,(7,14,28)
as supported by the development of fatigue following onset of pain,
improvement
of fatigue following a decrease in pain, greater the risks for
developing
fatigue with the longer duration of pain, and the increased chances for
onset of fatigue with the more intense pain.(7) Fatigue may
respond
to behavioral modification by incorporating aerobic exercise into their
lifestyles. As discussed below, patients without quadriplegia,
paraplegia,
severe orthopedic or rheumatologic deforming conditions or geriatric
patiens
with impaired balance should not be given handicapped parking.
However,
the nature of the disease often precludes the requisite participation
of
two months before the endogenous endorphin and enkephalin systems can
begin
to address the condition. As such, pharmacologic intervention is
often of great utility to facilitate aerobic exercise several times a
week.
Sedation related to opioids is somewhat
more
challenging to treat than some of the other opioid induced side
effects.
The clinician should first attempt to eliminate medications which are
contributing
to the sedation. If the patient states that they cannot work and
earn a living because of opioid induced sedation, then they should be
managed
with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories and other medications free of
cognitive
side effects. However, patients characteristically drive and
perform
quite well even with high dose opioids.( )
Tramodol
(Ultram) is an opioid with noradrenergic properties, such that it is
less
likely to induce sedation. Several different psychostimulants may
eliminate the sedation related to opioids to allow patients to continue
with these medications. Modafinil (Provigil), atomoxetine
(Strattera),
Protriptylline, and methylphenidate (Ritalin) may address daytime
sedation
which precludes work. Given its abuse potential and the host of
other
uncontrolled alternative options available, many pain management
clinicians
restrict prescription of Ritalin only to those individuals who work.
Considerable
evidence exists to support the cognitive safety of opioids in that they
do not preclude safe driving.(54) If opioids or other analgesics
result in sedation refractory to psychostimulants then the medication
should
be tapered. If no other analgesics are effective then
consideration
for referral for morphine/clinodome pump implantation should be
entertained.
Substitution of pain for coma quality of life is not acceptable in the
non-hospice setting.
Medication strategies include
dopaminergics,
noradrenergics, and serotoninergics.
COMORBID CHRONIC FATIGUE – TREATMENT–
MODAFINIL
Modafinil (Provigil) decreases fatigue
related
to fibromyalgia(33) as well as multiple sclerosis( ) and
other
chronic pain conditions. Modafinil has been described as
ameliorating
the opioid side effect of sedation.(90) Modafinil is distinct
from
methylphenidate in that it stimulates hypothalamic tuberomammillary
nucleus
pathways to the cerebral cortex without sympathomimetic effects to
increase
blood pressure or heart rate such that it appears safe even in the
presence
of coronary artery disease. However, dyspnea, palpitations,
angina,
and transient ischemic T-wave changes have been identified with
modafinl.(35)
Modafinil is also distinct from methylphenidate in that the former
medication
does not stimulate projections to the nucleus accumbens reward center
such
that potential for abuse is unremarkable.(90) This medication is
insoluble in water and so it cannot be injected, and it degrades when
heated
so it cannot be smoked.(90) Unlike the use of methylphenidate in
patients who decieve their physicians and solicit this noradrenergic
stimulant
to treat nonexistent pain and absent fatigue, modafinil does not have
euphoric
properties.(90)
Modafinil loses its effect in the presence
the
alpha-one receptor antagonists(35) given to treat neuropathic pain as
well
as urinary retention. It increases cerebral dopamine(35) such
that
postmarketing surveillance will need to define the extent of its safety
in patients with comorbid schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and other
mental
illness conditions. It has been hypothesized that modafinil may
decrease
the release of antinociceptive GABA neurotransmitter as well as
increase
nociceptive excitatory neurotransmitter glutamate(35) such that
postmarketing
surveillance will need to define if it has any detrimental effects on
pain
management. Modafinil has efficacy to treat mood
depression.(
)
Modafinil dosing should be lowered in
hepatic
failure as it is metabolized in this organ. Modafinil causes a
dose
dependent induction of CYP-3A4 450 isoenzymes at doses in excess of 400
mg such that reduced levels of carbamazepine, phenobarbital,
ketoconazole,
cyclosporine, and other CYP-3A4 metabolized medications which are
substrates
for biodegradation by the same enzyemes.(35) A dose dependent
induction
may also occur with CYP1A2 and CYP2B6 isoenzymes(35) with consequent
lowering
of serum levels of these medications. Modafinil inhibits CYP2C19
which metabolizes diazepam, phenytoin, and tricyclic antidepressants as
well as CYP2C9 which degrades warfarin and phenytoin(35) such that
modafinil
may result in accumulation of these other medications to toxic
levels.
The CYP-2C19 effects are reportedly only clinically relavant in the
presence
of 2YP-2D6 deficiency.(35)
COMORBID CHRONIC FATIGUE – TREATMENT–
ADDITIONAL
OPTIONS
Atomoxetine (Strattera) is a selective
norepinephrine
reuptake inhibitor. Upward titration whould be more gradual in
patients
consuming other CYP450 2D6 inhibitors as with paroxetine, fluoxetine,
and
quinidine.
Venlafaxine (Effexor) is a serotonin and
norepinephrine
reuptake inhibitor.
Bupropion has noradrenergic properties(5)
and
demonstrates efficacy to address chronic fatigue.
Protriptyline
Amantadine ( ) may decrease
fatigue,
and has been described as being efficious in multiple
sclerosis.(
)
Methylphenidate (Ritalin) is discussed in
detail
in this review as a psychostimulant narcotic which has potent
dopaminergic
and noradrenergic properties to treat fatigue, mood depression, and
pain.
Clinicians should prescribe this medication with caution as it has a
high
street value and induces euphoria in normal patients who lack
pain.(90)
It has the most marked efficacy in the treatment of profound
chemotherapy
related fatigue in the treatment of pain in oncology patients.
Chronic fatigue related to malnutrition as
in
oncology pain management may require appetite stimulants such as
oxandrolone,
dronabinol (Marinol) which also decreases pain and nausea, or
cyproheptadine
which may also decrease pain and pruritus as an anti-histamine.
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS
Before discussing the scope of analgesics,
it
is fundamental for any pain management practioner to understand that
nonopioid
analgesics often address pain just as well as opioids, even more so for
certain diagnoses. Before discussing individual analgesics,
it is important to discuss concepts of synergism, antagonism, and
common
general medication induced side effects. Medications from multiple
classes
may result in side effects. Side effects are best addressed
pro-actively
such that they can be extinguished pror to adding to morbidity.
Untreated
side effects contributes to noncompliance and unnecessary inadequacy of
treatment of the underlying pain.
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS –
ORTHOSTATIC
HYPOTENSION
Changing positions rapidly from supine to
standing
requires compensatory cardiovasculatory responses to prevent
pre-syncope
and falls. Many analgesics blunt these reflex responses through
various
mechanisms and unless the system is exogenously pharmacologically
enhanced
by the clinician, patients may not tolerate various analgesics.
Opioid
induced orthostatic hypotension occurs secondary to arterial
vasodilation
as well as venodilation with decreased cardiac return.
Medications
with potent anticholinergic properties such as amitriptyline (Elavil)
and
other tricyclic antidepressants as well as diphenhydramine (Benadryl)
and
other antihistamines predictably increase the risks for orthostasis.
Tricyclic antidepressants with alpha
antagonist
blocking properties as well as direct alpha antagonist
antihypertensives
such as terazosin (Hytrin), prazosin (Minipress), tamsulosin (Flomax),
and doxazosin (Cardura). Nifedipine (Adalat, Procardia) is an
L-subtype
calcium channel blocker analgesic and antihypertensive. Clonidine
and tizanidine (Zanaflex) are central alpha-2 agonists with analgesic
properties
which may reduce blood pressure. Medications which impair
cognition
and slow reaction time may also predispose to falls, particularly in
the
elderly.
Nonpharmacologic options include
maintenance
of good hydration, thigh high compressive stockings, abdominal binders,
elevating leg rests, slow postural changes, intermittent isometric
contractions, and biofeedback. If no
contra-indication
such as brittle congestive heart failure exists, salt tablets or salt
fortified
foods may result in passive water flow to increase intra-vascular
volume
and avoid
orthostasis. Fludrocortisone
(Flurinef)
may achieve a similar goal via sodium retention. Another option
is
use of Midodrine (ProAmitine) as a short duration of action alpha
agonist.
Methylphenidate (Ritalin) may also address orthostasis as a
noradrenergic
agonist. Orthostasis may also occur secondary to opioid mediated
bradycardia and this may respond to concomitant treatment with
nonopioid
analgesics with anticholinergic properties such as the tricyclic
antidepressants.
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS –
XEROSTOMIA
Dry mouth is not simply an irritating side
effect
of opioids, muscle relaxants, antidepressants, bupropion,(5) and other
analgesics. Excessively dry mouth with poor bathing of the gums
by
sublingual, parotid, and submandibular gland secretions can result in
peridontitis
and rapid loss of all teeth of the jaw. Highly anticholinergic
medications
which dry the mouth such as amitriptyline (Elavil) should be
substituted
for less potent anticholinergics such as nortriptyline (Pamelor) or
serotonergic
medications.
Treatment options may include over the
counter
Biotene (888-246-8363) in the form of toothpaste, antibacterial alcohol
free mouthwash, gel, and denture grip. Biotene contains
replacement
enzymes including lysozyme to split bacterial cell walls, lactoferrin
to
deprive iron needed for bacterial growth, and lactoperoxidase with
glucose
oxidase to inhibit bacterial growth by production of hypothicyanite ion.
Salivart (800-321-9348) is viscous
synthetic
over the counter saliva spray of saline with sorbitol and is approved
as
safe by the American Dental Association.
Sage Products (800-323-2220) produces Moist
Plus
Mouth Moisturizer and Toothette Oral Care to moisturize the mouth with
vitamin E and coconut oil. This company also produces Antiseptic
nonalcoholic Oral Rinse with oral enzymes.
Evoxac is a prescription medication which
stimulates
salivary production.
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS -
CONSTIPATION
Constipation is an extremely common side
effect
of opioid treatment and with every dose escalation the clinician should
ask the patient if this is a problem to avoid iatrogenic visceral pain
of obstipation. Failure to solicit symptoms of constipation from
patients reluctant to discuss this private issue results in unnecessary
suffering and may result in patients refusing to ingest opioids as well
as anticholinergic tricylcic antidepressants. First line
treatment
of constipation should include increasing hydration, physical activity,
and dietary fiber content and with over the counter psyllium products
such
as Konsyl, Metamucil, and Citrucel. Psyllium products may have
secondary
medical benefits of reducing cholesterol as well as risks for colon
cancer,
breast cancer, and atherosclerotic related myocardial ischemic and
stroke
events. If this strategy proves ineffective, then osmotic agents
such as Lactulose, MiraLax, and Kristallose as well as the fecal
lubricant
Colace should be prescribed. Osmotic agents are best described as
“sponge-like” as they absorb water to help the stool remain hydrated
and
slide through the intestines. In younger patients, the clinician
should strive to avoid regular use of stimulants as these impair the
integrity
of the intrinsic intestinal neural network if ingested for
years.(
) Intermittent use several times a month of stimulants such as
Senokot
is safe and efficacious. Colonic irrigation may disrupt
electrolyte
homeostasis with risks for cardiac arrhythmias and seizures, and should
be restricted for occasional use only with obstipation or fecal
obstruction.
MEDICATION INDUCED SIDE EFFECTS –
URINARY RETENTION
Urinary retention secondary to opioids
occurs
as a result of both increased tone of the external sphincter as well as
decreased tone of the urinary bladder.(23) Bladder distension
from
urinary retention may result in profound visceral pain. The
condition
may be addressed with Urecholine as a cholinergic agonist to enhance
bladder
contractility. Patients may require co-prescription of a proton
pump
inhibitor to block cholinergic muscarinic mediated increased gastric
acid
secretion with accompanying risks of peptic ulceration. Alpha
antagonists
terazosin (Hytrin), prazosin (Minipress), and doxazosin (Cardura)
(Flomax) may also be prescribed to relax internal smooth muscle
sphincter
tone, particularly in males in whom the muscle is considerably more
developed.
These agents may have dual utility to also diminish neuropathic pain,
but
the clinician will need to educate the patient regarding increased
risks
for orthostatic events, particularly if opioids are also prescribed
with
their venodilating effects and subsequent diminished cardiac
return.
The analgesic muscle relaxants lioresal (Baclofen) and tizanidine
(Zanaflex)
relax the striated skeletal muscle of the external urethral sphincter
to
facilitate voiding, and these agents may also diminish pain and address
pain related insomnia.
NON-ANALGESIC MEDICATIONS
A number of medications have been marketed
as
analgesics and have been inappropriately prescribed as
analgesics.
Better controlled studies reveal that these medications either lack
analgesic
properties or are vastly inferior to other medications prescribed for
the
same analgesic, anxiolytic, sedative, and spasmogenic properties.
Use of these two classes of medications have documented extensive
potential
for abuse in terms of euphoria and addiction. This author agrees
with the published literature in that the class of medications known as
benzodiazepines and barbiturates are to be prescribed only on rare
occasion,
such as a prescription for one tab of a benzodiazepine to allow a
patient
to tolerate the confines of an enclosed body MRI.
Carisoprodol (Soma) abuse increased
by
22% from 2000 to 2001(9) and it was ranked number 14 of 20 on the list
of abused drugs in 2000.(15) In Massachusetts and many states it
is Schedule IV controlled and it has considerable street criminal
diversion
value. Carisoprodol is metabolized to meprobamate, a barbiturate
and schedule IV drug. Carisoprodol is abused with cocaine(9) to
soften
the crash coming down from a cocaine euphoria. It is abused to
enhance
the euphoria of hydrocodone and it is also abused with tramodol(22) to
enhance euphoric psychotropic effects. Larege doses of
carisoprodol
may result in coma when co-prescribed with OxyContin.(6)
Carisoprodol
can result in euphoria and addiction(9) with patients discarding
familial
and work relationships and responsibilities in an all encompassing
pursuit
of the drug. Given the diversion and addiction issues, the fact
that
eight clinical trials demonstrated Soma to have efficacy comparable to
placebo, it has been suggested that this product be removed from the
market.(9)
Headaches often result in myofascial spasm
related
pain of the cervical spine with efficacy of TPI’s. Clinicians
should
be aware of the preventability of one cause of this condition in the
avoidance
of butalbital-acetaminophen-caffeine (Fioricet) and
butalbital-aspirin-caffeine
(Fiorinal) combinations given the presence of the barbiturate
butalbital.
This barbiturate has been linked to psychological dependency with
significant
abuse potential with “… no evidence in the literature demonstrating
benefit
over other agents or placebo [in the treatment of migraine
headaches].(
) It has been suggested by other authors that
“butalbital-containing
analgesics be banned.”( ) At the very least, given
the
enormous difficulty of detoxification from barbiturates relative to the
ease of opioid detoxification, it is suggested that the best strategy
is
to not start butalbital containing drugs which can transform episodic
uncomfortable
headaches to disabling chronic daily headaches.( )
Benzodiazepines include lorazepam (Ativan),
alprazolam
(Xanax), clonazepam (Klonopin), diazepam (Valium), temazepam
(Restoril),
triazolam (Halcion), midazolam, oxazepam (Serax), estazolam (Prosom),
flurazepam
(Dalmane), and chlordiazepoxide (Librium). “Benzodiazepine-like”
drugs include zolpidem (Ambien) and zaleplon (Sonata). Benzodiazepines
have been well documented to have limited efficacy to decrease
pain(
) and are felt by many pain management experts to be contra-indicated
in
chronic pain management.(75,99) Regular use increases the risks
for
the common physician induced problems of rebound insomnia,( )
rebound
increased anxiety,( ) and worsening or creation of mood
depression.(76)
This class of medication impaired attention, insight, judgement,
memory,
and other cognitive functions that are also compromised in
dementia.(76,78,83,92)
The individual often cannot appreciate the cognitive decline in
themselves,
just as the demented patient lacks insight into their own
deficits.
The impaired physician often self-prescribes or obtains
benzodiazepines.
Given their same risks for cognitive decline from these drugs relative
to patients, they often freely prescribe these agents until
surveillance
agencies help them into detoxification programs.
Benzodiazepines may antagonize opioid
induced
analgesic effects.(32) Benzodiazepines increase sensitivity to
pain
by the inhibition of serotonin neurotransmitter release.(75) This
may also be the mechanism by which benzodiazepines result in mood
depression.
Benzodiazepines have significant criminal diversion value to sell to
drug
addicts, as benzodiazepines are abused to soften the crash of coming
down
from a cocaine high.
Clonazepam results in side effects of mood
depression,
disinhibition, and sexual dysfunction.(76) Alprazolam and
lorazepam
result in drowsiness, mood depression, lethargy, impaired memory, and
compromised
intellectual function.(92) Alprazolam has also been discussed as
worsening post-traumatic stress disorder.(78)
ANALGESIC MEDICATIONS
It is often most valuable to visualize
analgesics
in terms of classes of anti-inflammatories, muscle relaxants,
anticonvulsants,
antidepressants, opioids, anti-arrhythmics, and novel atypical
agents.
The anti-inflammatories are particularly helpful as they do not simply
treat the potentially disabling symptom of pain, but they also may
facilitate
cure or delaying inexorable progression of pathology by modifying the
disease
course. Different classes of medications are best utilized to
treat
pain reflecting the mechanical, neuropathic, or visceral pain of which
the patient complains. Medications are selected based on safety,
comorbid conditions which may be addressed with the same analgesic, and
overall clinical presentation. It is the truly uncommon patient
whose
pain is maximally attenuated with just one analgesic, and standard of
care
is to utilize polypharmacy to take advantage of the different
mechanisms
of action of medications of different classes.( )
Nonopioid
analgesics may block pain such that lower opioid doses are required
with
accompanying lower opioid related side effects. Nonopioid
analgesics
not uncommonly will decrease pain as much as or even more so than
opioids.
Use of calcitonin may allow a decrease in the consumption of analgesic
medications(136) as well as complete withdrawal of opioid
requirements(155).
Clinicians who practice pain management
must
have the patience to not uncommonly prescribed dozens of trials of
medications
until the optimal strategy is defined.
Financial issues must be considered,
and
less expensive medications such as Baclofen, nortriptyline,
glucosamine,
chondroitin, generic opioids, and other agents must be considered.
Topical
phenytoin(242) and opioids(66,67) may decrease pain and are inexpensive
when crushed in water and applied to an area with neuropathic pain or
mechanical
pain related to burns or cutaneous ulcers.
The clinician has many options in terms of
narcotic
and nonnarcotic based analgesics which he should prescribe in accord
with
his training and experience. Safety, efficacy, and diversion
issues
determine which agent is selected as well as comorbid conditions.
One medication, for example, may address several conditions.
Analgesic potency may occur because of the
effectiveness
of a single mechanism or it may reflect a single medication effecting
antinociception
via activity of several analgesic pathways. In terms of a single
mechanism, local anesthetics act via impairing sodium conduction in the
periphery as a very potent isolated means by which pain is profoundly
extinguised.
Opioids, however, result in pain reduction by acting on sodium,
potassium,
and calcium channels. Similarly, zonisemide (Zonegran) acts via
sodium,
calcium, and GABA mechanisms to reduce pain.
Pain should be treated with vigor before
the
plasticity of the peripheral and central nervous systems magnify the
pain
to the point of true disability. This requires an aggressive,
polymodal
approach to address pain via several different mechanisms at several
different
anatomic sites to prevent the signal from reaching the consciousness of
the cerebral cortex. The additive analgesic effect of adding
several
drugs with distinctly different mechanisms of action supports the use
of
“rational polypharmacy” to target different pain mechanisms with
different
classes of medications(37) and also limit dose related side effects.
MEDICATIONS – SYNERGISM OF COMBINATIONS
OF ANALGESICS
A number of anti-nociceptive medications,
when
co-prescribed, result in much greater analgesia than that which is
expected
from simple addition of individual pain relieving properties. When two
potent analgesics are consumed together, one plus one may equal three
in
terms of the summed pain relief due to interactions amongst the two
populations
of receptors with consequent amplification of pain relief. The
concept
of supra-additivity / potentiation / synergism is best explained to the
patient by analogy. Just as chocolate and peanut butter are
individually
delicious, when added together to form a Reese’s peanut butter cup the
combined flavor is greater than the individual sums of the two
ingredients.
This greater antinociception than predicted from simple additivity may
reflect interaction between secondary mediators of receptors, and
allows
for lower dosing than expected of each individual analgesic with
accompanying
decreased side effects. Conversely, adding a synergistic agent to
a patient’s regimen should allow a decrease in the opioid dose without
any decrement in analgesic efficacy.
With respect to specific combinations
confering
supra-additive analgesia, low doses of methylphenidate and
dextroamphetamine
potentiate the effects of morphine analgesia.(250) Calcitonin
potentiates
the analgesia induced by the serotonergic antidepressants.(189)
Clonidine,
when co-prescribed with morphine, may yield greater than additive
potentiated
pain relief of each individual analgesic.(40) The L-subtype
channel
antagonist nifedipine potentiates morphine induced analgesia.(63)
Morphine,
when combined with L-methadone, delivers analgesic synergy with greater
anti-nociception relative to the sum of additive analgesia from the two
analgesics.(12) One of the greatest benefits of dronabinol is its
synergy with the opioids to decrease pain.(121,122,125,126) Local
anesthetics potentiate opioid related analgesia,(67) and this explains
the vast synergistic improvement in pain and function with a
combination
of opioid and local anesthetic injections. Antihistamines may
markedly
potentiate opioids, including pentazocine, morphine, fentanyl, and
nalbuphine.(149,179,180)
MEDICATIONS – ANTAGONISM OF COMBINATIONS
OF ANALGESICS
Because fast kinetic blockade by lidocaine
may
compete with propoxyphene slow kinetic blockade, less sodium channel
blockade
has been observed during exposure to the combination of propoxyphene
and
lidocaine relative to lidocaine alone,(202) suggesting that these
medications
or systemic local anesthetic mexiletine (Mexitil) should not be
concomitantly
delivered to decrease pain. Prior induction of morphine tolerance
has been identified as enhancing the toxicity of norpropoxyphene,(203)
suggesting that combination of these two opioids may not be an optimal
management strategy. Odansetron blocks the analgesia of tramodol
(Ultram).( ) Modafinil loses its effect in the presence the
alpha-one receptor antagonists(35) Methylphenidate should not be
given to patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy as this condition
is
sympathetically maintained and the potent noradrenergic properties of
methylphenidate
often intensify the pain.
Cumulative pro-convulsant side
effects
must be considered when co-prescribing tricyclic anti-depressants,
serotonergic
antidepressants, bupropion (Wellbutrin SR, Zyban) olanzepine (Zyprexa),
and tramodol (Ultram), suggesting benefit to co-prescribe
anticonvulsant
analgesics if combinations of these pro-convulsant analgesics are
prescribed.
Cardiac toxicity may not be a clinical
issue
when prescribed in isolation, but consideration for alternative agents
may or may not be advisable with other cardio-excitatory medications
such
as 5-HT3 agonists, propoxyphene,( ) methylphenidate,
mexiletene,
and tricyclic antidepressants.( )
MEDICATIONS – GLUCOSAMINE AND CHONDROITIN
Glucosamine sulfate is a normal
constituent
of cartilage glycosaminoglycan and slowly decreases knee pain within
two
weeks of ingestion, and slowly acts to address the radiologic joint
space
narrowing correlating with loss of joint cartilage such that after
three
years of use 0.27 mm more cartilage is present in treated as opposed to
untreated patients.(1) This is significant as the healthy
aticular
cartilage diameter is 1-2 mm thick( ) and 0.27 divided by
1.5
mm is approximately 20%, quite a substantial increase in cartilage for
a medication with such an innocuous side effect profile.
Glucosamine
has also been shown to decrease hip pain,( ) and build cartilage
in the hip.( )
Chondroitin sulfate is a normal
component
of cartilage that slowly decreases joint pain over two weeks and
radiographic
progression of joint space narrowing over months.(1) Chondroitin
is synergistic with glucosamine such that both medications should be
delivered
simultaneously.( )
As the facet joints are lined with
cartilage,
patients with lower back pain secondary to arthropathy at these joints
may also be expected to benefit from glucosamine.( )
In addition, patients who are status post cervical or lumbar
laminectomy
are at risk for advanced progression of osteoarthritis after
stabilizing
elements of bone have been extracted such that these patients may also
benefit from glucosamine and chondroitin.( ) Glucosamine and
chondroitin
have side effect profiles similar to placebo.(1) It is important
to instruct patients to purchase these products from reputable stores
and
manufacturers as the FDA chose to not monitor these medications and
unscrupulous
individuals may sell pharmacologically inactive placebo flour or sugar
products. Patients with the spectrum of mild to moderate to
severe
osteoarthritis appreciate improvement with glucosamine and
chondoitin.(1)
MEDICATIONS - ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES – ORAL
STEROIDS
Corticosteroids inhibit
antiphospholipase-A2.
Arichidonic acid, a membrane phospholipid, is metabolized in the
presence
of inflammation into cyclooxygenase (COX) products of prostaglandins
(PG’s)
and thromboxanes as well as metabolized into lipoxygenase products of
leukotrienes
(LT) and lipoxins.(16) Corticosteroids may also directly reduce
peripheral
neuronal excitability via activity at cell membranes as well as
decrease
pain via neurotransmitter mediated central effects.(32) Steroids
also have been discussed as blocking afferent C-fiber
nociception.(254)
When prescribed at high dose taper for one week in the form of a Medrol
dose pack it may decrease inflammation and pain without disrupting the
endocrine hypothalamic – anterior pituitary – adrenal medulla
axis.(
) It should be utilized with caution in brittle diabetics as it
may
precipitate hyperglycemic reactions. Similarly, prednisone should
be utilized with caution in the immunocompromised as ste |